1. If a recipe is savory, it has to have some form of pork fat in it.
2. If a recipe is sweet, it must have loads of butter and/or cream cheese.
I'm putting this recipe in category two because it lacks pork fat and, well, they're cookies. Why boy catcher cookies? Because boys love them. I'm not saying that this is why I bake them (or have in the past), but boys go absolutely gaga over these cookies (if they're not chocolate hating freaks). The actual name is Paula Dean's "Chocolate Gooey Butter Cookies" and you can find the original recipe here.
Let's get started. This is actually a cookie recipe where you don't have to worry about preheating the oven, because the dough has to chill. You do, however, have to remember to take out the butter and cream cheese so they can come to room temperature. Here's the ingredients you need to gather:
- 1 stick butter
- 1 brick cream cheese (I get the neufchatel cheese because it has less fat, but full fat works too)
- 1 egg
- 1 tsp vanilla extract
- 1 box chocolate cake mix (I like devil's food, but use whatever strikes your fancy)
- Enough powdered sugar to coat the cookies
That's it as far as ingredients go. Once your butter and cream cheese are room temperature, cream them together. I used a stand mixer because I have one, but a hand mixer will work as well. After those are combined, add the egg and vanilla and stir again until completely combined. Stop the mixer, scrape down the bowl, add the cake mix and turn the mixer back on.. The texture of the dough is going to change drastically in just a few minutes. You'll go from something resembling cake batter to this:
At this point, the dough needs to chill before it can be formed into cookies. There's a lot of soft dairy, so it's important to get the dough really cold so it won't just melt into your palms. Usually you chill it in the fridge for two hours, but I was feeling impatient, so decided to give a shorter time in the freezer a try. I divided the dough into four discs, wrapped them in plastic wrap, and put them in the freezer for 15 minutes.
And what do you know, it worked. I pulled out one disc at a time, and started rolling the cookies. Once you pull the dough out of wherever you choose to chill it, preheat the oven to 350 degrees. Pull off tablespoon-sized hunks and roll them between your palms to form balls. Roll the balls in powdered sugar and place on a baking sheet. The recipe says it makes 2 dozen cookies and I usually get between 24 and 30, depending on how evenly I roll out the dough. You don't need to grease the cookie sheets (there's quite enough butter in the cookies). Bake the cookies for 12 minutes, and then let them cool completely before you try to move them. The shape doesn't change much from raw to cooked, and they remain very delicate and soft.
And what do you know, it worked. I pulled out one disc at a time, and started rolling the cookies. Once you pull the dough out of wherever you choose to chill it, preheat the oven to 350 degrees. Pull off tablespoon-sized hunks and roll them between your palms to form balls. Roll the balls in powdered sugar and place on a baking sheet. The recipe says it makes 2 dozen cookies and I usually get between 24 and 30, depending on how evenly I roll out the dough. You don't need to grease the cookie sheets (there's quite enough butter in the cookies). Bake the cookies for 12 minutes, and then let them cool completely before you try to move them. The shape doesn't change much from raw to cooked, and they remain very delicate and soft.
If I'm packing the cookies for travel (say to a boy's house) I put layers of parchment paper in between, and limit them to two layers. Happy baking and good luck with your catching.